| WEST FIRST TEAM | Year | Position | School |
| Jordan Thys*** | Sr. | Pitcher | Benton |
| Josh Loren*** | Sr. | Pitcher | CCA |
| Jack Downes*** | Sr. | Catcher | CCA |
| Lane Kaestner*** | Sr. | Infield | Benton |
| Ben Hakert*** | Sr. | Infield | CPU |
| Nile Sinn*** | So. | Infield | Williamsburg |
| Wyatt Rinderknecht | Jr. | Outfield | Benton |
| Trevor Antes | Jr. | Outfield | CPU |
| Kaden Phan*** | So. | Outfield | CCA |
| Drew Fillenworth*** | Fr. | Utility | Benton |
| Drake VanGorder*** | Jr. | Utility | CPU |
| ***Unanimous Selection | |||
| SECOND TEAM | |||
| Trey O’Neil | Sr. | Pitcher | Williamsburg |
| Grant Goebel | Sr. | Pitcher | CPU |
| Cael Kaestner | Sr. | Catcher | Benton |
| Evan Daugherty | Sr. | Infield | Benton |
| Reece Hoffman | Sr. | Infield | CCA |
| Bryer Wiley | Jr. | Infield | CPU |
| Owen Mullinex | Jr. | Outfield | VS |
| Madox Doehrmann | Sr. | Outfield | Williamsburg |
| Sam Rich | Sr. | Outfield | Williamsburg |
| Ryan Finn | Jr. | Utility | Benton |
| David Williams | Sr. | Utility | CCA |
| WAMAC RECOGNITION | |||
| Cody Wright | Benton | ||
| Easton Patterson | Benton | ||
| Thomas Taylor | CPU | ||
| Jonah DuPont | CPU | ||
| Maclane Morgan | CCA | ||
| Caleb Allan | CCA | ||
| Easton Almquist | Vinton-Shellsburg | ||
| Mason Coder | Vinton-Shellsburg | ||
| Daniel Wiese | South Tama | ||
| Nolan Upah | South Tama | ||
| Rayce Heitman | Williamsburg | ||
| Landon Jepson | Williamsburg | ||
| Player of the Year | Jordan Thys | Benton Community |
| EAST FIRST TEAM | Year | Position | School |
| Peyton Aldrich*** | Sr. | Pitcher | West Delaware |
| Keegan Palmer*** | Sr. | Pitcher | Independence |
| Kaden Frommelt*** | Sr. | Catcher | Marion |
| Brett White*** | Jr. | Infield | Solon |
| Myles Davis*** | Jr. | Infield | Marion |
| Tyrus Werner*** | Sr. | Infield | West Delaware |
| Blake Timmons*** | Sr. | Outfield | Solon |
| Trey Franck*** | Jr. | Outfield | Marion |
| Maddox Lott*** | Sr. | Outfield | West Delaware |
| Brent Yonkovic*** | So. | Utility | West Delaware |
| Colin Bentley*** | So. | Utility | Mount Vernon |
| ***Unanimous Selection | |||
| SECOND TEAM | Year | Position | School |
| Bryce Christian | Fr. | Pitcher | Independence |
| Brick Kabela | Jr. | Pitcher | Solon |
| Gehrig Turner | Jr. | Catcher | Solon |
| Jake Miller | So. | Infield | Marion |
| Mitch Johnson | Sr. | Infield | Independence |
| Korver Hupke | Sr. | Infield | Independence |
| Will Ward | Sr. | Outfield | West Delaware |
| Hayden Lyness | Sr. | Outfield | West Delaware |
| Christopher Meyer | Fr. | Outfield | Independence |
| Isaac Scott | Jr. | Utility | Marion |
| Jackson Link | So. | Utility | Solon |
| WAMAC RECOGNITION | |||
| Coda Johnson | Jr. | Marion | |
| Isaiah Scott | Freshman | Marion | |
| Nolan Seagren | So. | Solon | |
| Vince Steinbrch | Jr. | Solon | |
| Maddox Rollinger | Sr. | Mt. Vernon | |
| Anthony McDermott | So. | Mt. Vernon | |
| Sam Niles | Sr. | West Delaware | |
| Keegan Jackson | So. | West Delaware | |
| Andrew Rottinghaus | So | Independence | |
| Trey Weber | Jr. | Independence | |
| Player of the Year | |||
| Brett White | Jr. | Solon | |
| Kaden Frommelt | Sr. | Marion |
Jim Magdefrau 