| 2020 SICL All-Conference | ||
| 1st Team | ||
| Pitchers (3) | Grade | School |
| *Denali Conover | Jr. | Lynnville-Sully |
| Madison McKay | Jr. | North Mahaska |
| Kylie Doty | Soph. | Colfax-Mingo |
| Catchers (2) | Grade | School |
| Korrine Jansen | Jr. | Lynnville-Sully |
| Maci DeJong | Sr. | North-Mahaska |
| Infielders (5) | Grade | School |
| *Megan Stuhr | Sr. | Sigourney |
| Lilly Parrott | Sr. | Belle Plaine |
| Mallory Loftus | Sr. | Lynnville-Sully |
| Caitlyn Alberts | Jr. | Lynnville-Sully |
| Gwen Mews | Soph. | English-Valleys |
| Outfielders (4) | Grade | School |
| *Laci Keen | Jr. | Lynnville-Sully |
| Chloe Bossard | Sr. | North Mahaska |
| Taylor Moel | Jr. | BGM |
| Caylee Cunningham | Fr. | Colfax-Mingo |
| Utility (2) | Grade | School |
| Abi Rawlins | Fr. | Colfax-Mingo |
| Kaleah Ehresman | Sr. | Lynnville-Sully |
| Kiley Alcott | So. | Belle Plaine |
| Morgan Hudson | So. | North Mahaska |
| 2nd Team | ||
| Pitchers (3) | Grade | School |
| *Hannah Marsh | Jr. | English Valleys |
| Kallie Robison | Fr. | Montezuma |
| Carly Goodwin | 8th | Sigourney |
| Catchers (2) | Grade | School |
| Carissa VanZee | Sr. | Montezuma |
| Kaylee Weber | Jr. | Sigourney |
| Infielders (5) | Grade | School |
| Addy Westfall | Fr. | English Valleys |
| Carley Underwood | Fr. | Colfax-Mingo |
| Kayla Jack | Jr. | HLV |
| Rylie VanErsvelde | Sr. | BGM |
| Zoe Duecore | Soph. | North Mahaska |
| Outfielders (4) | Grade | School |
| *Karlee Chandler | Sr. | North Mahaska |
| Maddie Mikesell | Soph. | English Valleys |
| Olivia Bohlen | Soph. | Belle Plaine |
| Courtney Hemsley | Fr. | Sigourney |
| Utility (2) | Grade | School |
| Karlee Timm | Jr. | HLV |
| Cayler Noun-Harder | Jr. | Lynnville-Sully |
| Conference Coach of the Year: Stacey Alberts – Lynnville Sully |
- Unanimous
Jim Magdefrau 