| FIRST TEAM | Year | Position | School |
| ***Kaden Fisher | Senior | Pitcher | Vinton-Shellsburg |
| ***Blayne Roberts | Senior | Pitcher | CCA |
| ***Henry Simmons | Senior | Catcher | Williamsburg |
| ***Brooks Vosburg | Junior | Grinnell | |
| ***Drew Fillenworth | Senior | Benton | |
| ***Luke Young | Junior | CCA | |
| ***Carson Grier | Senior | Williamsburg | |
| ***Josh Ringler | Junior | Grinnell | |
| ***Eli Patterson | Senior | Benton | |
| Kale Gallagher | Senior | Benton | |
| ***Brooks Birdsell | Junior | Benton | |
| ***Unanimous Selection | |||
| SECOND TEAM | Year | Position | School |
| Daxton Flanagan | Sophomore | Pitcher | Grinnell |
| Alex DuBay | Junior | Pitcher | CCA |
| Weston Kaestner | Senior | Catcher | Benton |
| Trenten Huls | Junior | Grinnell | |
| Grady Frese | Senior | Benton | |
| Grant Volesky | Senior | Benton | |
| Silas Cobb | Junior | CCA | |
| Levi Jack | Junior | Grinnell | |
| Kaleb Hupke | Junior | Benton | |
| Texton Bollers | Sophomore | CCA | |
| Logan Schmidt | Senior | Williamsburg | |
| WAMAC RECOGNITION | |||
| Wyatt Key | Senior | UTL | CCA |
| Talen Hoffman | Senior | UTL | CCA |
| Cash Brown | Sophomore | Infield | Williamsburg |
| Bowen Stratton | Senior | Outfield | Williamsburg |
| Easton Edelen | Junior | Outfield | Grinnell |
| Kamdon Harms | Junior | Pitcher | Grinnell |
| Carson Nolan | Senior | Benton | |
| Colton Kroneman | Junior | Benton | |
| Jonas Sheetz | Sophomore | South Tama County | |
| Brayden Wiese | Freshman | South Tama County | |
| Jacoby Johnson | Senior | VS | |
| Jack Blais | Senior | VS | |
| Player of the Year | |||
| Luke Young | Junior | CCA | |
Jim Magdefrau 